Wednesday, 11 May 2011

The first year of marriage

Today marks the first anniversary of the ConLib coalition. The Conservatives entered the marriage with 307 seats against the 57 of their Liberal bedfellows. Of course every marriage needs compromise from both sides and politics is no different. However, to coin Orwell in Animal Farm,"All animals are equal except some are more equal than others". With 307 seats versus 57 seats the inequality speaks for itself. One year later, we have just had the referendum on the alternative voting system, the local elections and the elections for the national assemblies of Wales and Scotland. If the latter are a judgment on both sides in this coalition, the conclusions for each are in stark contrast. The Conservatives, surprisingly for a majority governing party, have been given a universal seal of approval. That they have failed so miserably in Scotland is entirely in line with expectations as the memory of Mrs. Thatcher is alive and well in the hearts and minds of the Scots. By contrast, the Liberals have been not so much chastised as assaulted! Their small gain in Wales was more a reflection of the nuances of Welsh politics. Elsewhere the message to them has been emphatic. To enter into a coalition espousing the best interests of the country is admirable but to then subsequently break most of your manifesto promises along the way is quite another. Even politicians need an element of credibility and I fear that the Liberals lost theirs twelve months ago. To agree to forfeit the lion's share of your election manifesto in exchange for a vote on something which wasn't even your preferred electoral system is at best weak and at worst stupid. In a way, they had to enter the coalition since this represented their only viable chance of being in government. A minority led Conservative government would simply have gone back to the country in the Autumn and acquired the majority which they needed. Hence, it always appeared that it was heads (the conservatives win) or tails (the conservatives win). Clegg ought to have stuck to his principles and put his money where his mouth is and demanded no less than a vote on proportional representation. He may not have won this vote but it would have had two key advantages. Firstly, PR was what his party has been campaigning for since before I was in short trousers and secondly, PR can be explained with ease to anyone - unlike the alternative voting system! I consider myself to be reasonably well informed but I'm buggered if anyone over the past month ever coherently explained how the alternative voting system actually works. That he chose to pursue a referendum on a system to which he did not subscribe and which he patently didn't understand is difficult to understand.

He speaks now of flexing his party's muscles more in government but doesn't seem to see that his strength is now akin to that of Daniel after his haircut. He is now between the devil and the deep blue sea. Flex his muscles and make himself look even more stupid (scarcely believable) or adopt a more subservient and acquiescent style with the latter removing what little credibility he may have left. To leave the coalition would be suicidal because, ironically, he would now be even weaker outside of it. Thus, I fully expect the coalition to see out its five years in government with the Conservatives being returned as the majority government in its wake.

Twelve months hence, we shall all doubtless be considering the first year of marriage of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge. I trust they both know what they seek out of their coalition and hope they have the strength to stick to their respective guns. Mr Clegg has sought popularity and the limelight and both have now betrayed him. The Duke and Duchess would be well advised to avoid both.

Friday, 29 April 2011

The Dust Settles

When John Steinbeck wrote The Grapes Of Wrath he inadvertently provided great material for devotees of the pun such as I.

I write this the evening after the evening before. Permit me to explain. Yesterday afternoon at times varying between half past four and five o clock in the afternoon, over a hundred third year medical students at Keele University put down their pens for the last time at the end of our final third year exams. Medicine is a bit of a slog. Not the sort of thing one turns to to fill a couple of hours on Tuesday evenings. It is a relentless avalanche of information being exposed to a cohort of students over a five year period in the vain hope that some of it might stick. You may imagine the relief which I felt as I departed the Examination Hall yesterday with the exams now firmly in my rear view mirror. Oh yes, John Steinbeck. Rather than the Grapes Of Wrath this morning, I fear that it was the Wrath Of Grapes which exacted its revenge following the celebrations of last night - deserved though they were.

However, the fact remains that I, along with my esteemed colleagues, am rather like Kermit The Frog's nephew Robin in the 1980 song: Halfway Down The Stairs. We're not at the bottom but neither are we are the top. In other words, we still have some way to go with more exams to negotiate. The snag is that as with any ladder, the further you ascend, the further there is to fall should one lose one's grip. Do you see what I mean? The more pressure we deal with, the more pressure we generate. I wonder, could this be an allegory for life itself? Perhaps.

So how does a medical student cope when the dust begins to settle the day after the exams? Early days for me but I can freely admit it is difficult sometimes. To be a tap which can be turned on and off at will is not without its challenges. That being said I have no regrets about choosing medicine. On the 5th of June it will be five years since our beautiful daughter Thea died. If I have no other motivation to carry on studying, the memories of Thea will sustain me forever. I can't bring her back but I can't forget her unique sparkle.

To all my colleagues, I wish you a long, hot summer in the company of those you love and those who love you.

Tuesday, 5 April 2011

When time stood still

Yesterday, as a third year medical student, I dutifully attended my OSCE assessment stations. I can best compare this to anyone else queueing up for the biggest roller coaster at Alton Towers. The conjecture regarding what lay ahead of us a seemingly endless series of conspiracy theory and personal nemeses. As we were led upstairs to where the examination stations were situated, the feelings of escalating upwards at the start of a roller coaster ride came flooding back. As with the roller coaster ride, it was all over so quickly - nigh on three hours! If anyone was studying medicine for the purpose of financial gain at the end of it all, this is the equivalent of those Japanese TV programmes first championed by Clive James in the 1980s. These programmes were a vehicle for people to show off their unfeasible appetites for masochism on scales hitherto unthought of. We all hope of course to have performed with few enough mistakes to be deemed worthy of progression to our next year of study were we will doubtless be subjected to ever higher levels of difficulty. No, you're quite right - logic has nothing to do with it. Ironic for a group of students considered to be of above average intelligence...

Sunday, 6 February 2011

What's In A Name?

In Medicine, there exists a well established desire to have syndromes, diseases and procedures named after a particular person or place.

Liverpool has attached its name to the now familiar "end of life care pathway". For the great good acheived by this approach, Liverpool must take great pride in its association with something so meaningful.

Glasgow has attached itself to the Glasgow Coma Scale in which patients are assessed very quickly to ascertain their level of consciousness. In the sphere of Intensive Care, the GCS, as it is often abbreviated, is de rigeur.

New York is now synonymous with the assessment of gravity of heart failure and has been adopted world-wide to provide a clear pathway to teatment.

However, for all the great merit of the afore mentioned triumvirate, it is surely Bristol who have really stolen the lime-light. What drives a given researcher or physician to decide to classify anything is intriguing. However, what drove anybody to decide to grade stools with a mark of 1 to 7 is truly mind boggling. The hours of dedication assessing countless samples of effluvia is both admirable and somewhat teutonic. As a pre-clinical undergraduate I used to have visions of arriving on the wards to be greeted by a row of beds above each of which stood a numeral of judgement on their every movement - if you'll pardon the pun. I envisaged covert conversations taking place between medics and nurses along the lines of "We've got a 7 in bed 5 - watch your step" or " The poor fellow in bed 9 is a 1 and its been 3 weeks now - you have to feel sorry for him".

So hats of to Bristol for providing endless hours of mirth to medical students everywhere. Let us also spare a thought for all those grade 1 patients who dream of their next motion and all those grade 7's who would just like 5 minutes respite....

Friday, 29 October 2010

Musical reunions

I note with passing interest today that hysteria has been reborn with the release of tickets to see Take That. Quite why, I can't imagine because to the best of my knowledge they weren't that good first time around and, in the musical instrument stakes, Led Zeppelin appear safe for the time being.

I can understand reunions for the sake of generating more money but frankly, this motive has gone past the point of boredom and has now sneaked into the ominous territory of tiresome. The reunions which interest me are those where money is of no consequence and the only issue revolves around the resolution of artistic difference. So, if Pink Floyd were to reform properly and more pertinently record new material to augment their legendary back catalogue, I would be very interested. The death two years ago of Rick Wright, their keyboard maestro would however render any proper reunion rather shallow.

Therefore, I started thinking about the potential reunions out there which could be made with all previous personnel, with no financial need and where the group in question was highly significant. It becomes difficult. The Who are missing their entire rhythm section, The Jimmy Hendrix Experience is now called Noel Redding, The Beatles are now Paul and a somewhat garbled Ringo, The Faces are minus Ronnie Lane and the Small Faces are minus Ronnie Lane and Steve Marriot. Led Zepellin would now be confined to being acoustic, The Doors would be an instrumental trio and God Bless them, The Bonzo Dog Doo Dah Band would have to take to the stage minus Vivyan Stanshall. The latter would be unthinkable as evidenced when I went to see them three years ago. Phil Jupitus is many things but Viv Stanshall he is not and never will be. Incidentally, viewing rare footage of the original Bonzos performing Little Sir Echo for German television is a glimpse of Stanshall at his very best.

The sad passing of Pete Quaife in June this year put the skids on any potential Kinks reunion and the passing of Brian Jones at the House At Pooh Corner in 1969 put the kybosh on any serious Stones revival. There is one from the sixties which is theoretically acheivable; Deep Purple. Whether Ian Gillan and Ritchie Blackmore could be persuaded to inhabit the same county again is open to debate.

I think perhaps the Sixties holds no remaining possibilities worthy of consideration. However, from the 1970s two outstanding examples have indeed reformed quite recently and sadly I wasn't able to see either; The Police and The Specials. Thankfully no such reunion is on the cards for Scotland's finest - The Bay City Rollers!

Thursday, 14 October 2010

Both sides now

It is said that the Canadian folk singer Joni Mitchell penned the lyrics for her song "Clouds" as a mere teenager. If you've ever heard this song, you will appreciate how astonishing this is. Well, like Joni, I too have looked at life from both sides now. As I embark on my clinical training interviewing and examining patients in a hospital setting, I still see each patient as myself. Let me explain. When I found myself in hospital in the New Year of 2005 I didn't know what had hit me. Finding myself with failed health in hospital did not fit with my life plan. However, I had to adapt to that environment and, as best as I could, accept it. I was lucky to have a loving family and many friends who showed me how much they cared. I encountered a wide variety of compassion in the medical professionals. Some were indifferent to me. Some were just too busy to have the time to show any compassion. Some were born to be in that profession. I was the patient and they left me in no doubt about it. Despite the fact that they were very busy, they still found the time to talk to me as a person - not as a patient. This is surely the greatest gift of all and the one to which I aspire. I have great compassion for those whose conditions leave them with little or no function but I have even greater compassion for those who have nobody in the world who cares for them. Surely this is the saddest situation of them all. We all need to be loved and to know that somebody cares irrespective of their relationship to us. As a society, how can we have come so far in so many ways and yet receeded so far where it really counts? I would rather be working in a run down hospital where every patient had at least one visitor who came to see them because they cared rather than a new hospital where patients languished anaesthetised by the effects of no love. I have just bought a pharmacy text-book laden with a plethora of weird and wonderful drugs but it seems to me that the most important drug of all is not listed.

Tuesday, 3 August 2010

Long live the amateur!

As Liverpool football club come to the end of their search for a new owner to pay off their reported debts of about 237 million pounds, I sit and wonder what became of the amateur tradition. Liverpool, in truth, are less seeking a new owner than a benefactor. I deplore the way in which professional sport has descended into such an economic mess. If you went to a casino to play roulette, and the croupier offered you 2 to 1 against an individual number, you wouldn't even waste your money. But this is not far away from the absurd chances facing the vast majority of professional football clubs and particularly those in the premier league. Of course, it is not only football which has descended into this unsustainable financial format. Cricket is slowly dying and too few people can even see it. I read today that Lancashire have elected not to play Andrew Flintoff in a second eleven fixture against Yorkshire this week. Of all the non stories swimming around in this the proverbial "silly season", this one takes some beating. Andrew Flintoff was finished as a top player about three years ago. The only reason he is retained as a county player is for the potential to cash in on him as a marketable commodity. However, while he lies by the side of his swimming pool in Dubai drawing his hefty salary for doing nothing, I can only hope that a young talent who will appreciate the opportunity will make a name for himself in this Roses match.

It is remarkably only 57 years since England appointed their first professional captain in the shape of the late, great Len Hutton. Can any of us now imagine an amateur being appointed again? Can we even envisage an England cricket captain actually being at least born in England?

Last week, I went to watch a local football match. In the Vale of Clwyd where I live, there is an annual inter village football competition involving about a dozen villages. There is a season long league followed by a knockout cup competition. It is about as amateur as you can get. Any rolling around on the floor to try and attract the attention of the referee will go unnoticed and if you persist, a chap will run run on to the pitch with a sponge and a bucket of water and just throw the water over you. No prima donnas here! No half hearted tackles either. Tackles are enough to make a surgeon purr with anticipation and those with a delicate constitution are best advised to look the other way. Afterwards, all and sundry retire to the pub and all animosities on the pitch are forgotten about. With the sole exception of a local business sponsoring the shirts on their backs, this has nothing to do with money and is so much more real and enjoyable as a result. The passion in the players is palpable and the only prize at stake is to be able to say that your side won. This is sport at its best and I feel that too many people have lost sight of this. If Liverpool owe 1 million or 200 million pounds, it means nothing to me as I am not in the least bit interested. As far as I'm concerned, the best result would be for one of these so called "big" clubs to go under and cease to exist thus creating a knock effect to the rest. The whole model of the modern professional game is unsustainable, boring and frankly, vulgar.

I can only hope that the pendulum begins to swing back in the amateur direction again for the good of sport everywhere. That way both the participants and the spectators will be all the richer for it.